Beating sense into the day's news

September 22, 2004

More MSM Journalists Pile On

Kathleen Parker in the Charlotte Observer has an insightful column on Rathergate, noting what Rather and the rest of the CBS crew seem to be trying to gloss-over: that they willfully ignored what their own document "experts" were telling them about the memos:

CBS may have been misled, but no one at the network was blindly misled. Rather and the network's producers had ample advance warning from their own document analysts that the memos' authenticity could not be confirmed with 100 percent confidence.
Of four experts consulted, two raised questions about various aspects of the documents, and at least one warned that they weren't quite ready for prime time. CBS ran the story anyway.
It's disingenuous for the network to say it was misled as though everything had been airtight. Where there is reasonable doubt about damning documents, especially proffered in an election season against a commander in chief during war, there is no story. No one at CBS doesn't know this.

She wraps up her column with what would surely cut Mr. Rather to the quick: an unfavorable comparison to Donald Rumsfeld:

His apology is what one might expect from a teenager when he gets caught smoking in the garage: "I used bad judgment, and for that I'm sorry." How about this instead: "I knowingly used questionable documents to damage a president during an election, and I have no excuse."
Or this, which is what Americans have a right to expect from adults whose powerful position can sway the course of human history: "These events occurred on my watch. I am accountable for them, and I take full responsibility." Doubtless it was painful for Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld to speak those words before the Senate Armed Services Committee last May following the story about prisoner abuse at Abu Ghraib prison, which Rather also broke on "60 Minutes II."
You'd think Rather might have taken notes.

Ouch.

Posted by Deus Ex Macrame at September 22, 2004 02:21 AM | TrackBack
Comments

For YEARS, CBS has been trying to breathe life into a "story" consisting exclusively of rumors almost certainly spawned by the Texas Democratic Party. AFAIK, NO credible evidence has EVER been found to substantiate these rumors.

Finally, CBS and RATHER and MAPES "find" bogus documents that -- THEY SAY -- provided the foundation they needed in order to air a "story" they'd been lusting after for years. Problem is, their "process" is defective; i.e., the documents are fakes -- and they have good reason to suspect they're fakes -- but hey, they wanted to air their B/S anyway BECAUSE THEY BELIEVE IN THE "STORY"! What they didn't admit was that without the authority of those documents, they have NO CREDIBLE EVIDENCE AT ALL!

This was "JOURNALISM?" This was politically motivated character assassination.

This was 'The National Enquirer' live and in living color.

Rather should go. Mapes should go. President of CBS News should go.

Posted by: Mannie at September 22, 2004 01:42 PM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?