Beating sense into the day's news

September 27, 2004

Death to America, Daddy-O

I don't know about you, but if a week goes by in which I haven't been lectured in ponderous tones as to why Americans are so hated, I feel all empty inside. So to fill the gaping void in my soul, I rooted around and found this article, in which the author ponders "the reason which has prompted growing distaste for us in a country which is our oldest ally and dearest Continental friend." Here's a sampling:

Before World War II the writer once engaged in argument with the buxom, faintly mustachioed patronne of a small Paris bistro. "Ah," said she by way of summing up, "you Americans were chics in 1917 -- not now."
We who were so chics in 1917 and again a quarter of a century later are no longer popular in France. This is one of the disappointing features disclosed by the present crisis. On both extreme Left and extreme Right an ugly current of anti-American feeling is running. Why?

I know, you're thinking that you know the answer to this one. It's because of George Bush -- his arrogant smirk, his swaggering unilateralism, and his obsession with oil (the French would never let their foreign policy be tainted by oil concerns) caused our faithful friends the French to turn away in disgust, right?

Well, there's just one problem with that theory: the article in question was written in 1958, when George Bush was ten years old. If you're scratching your head as to how the French could have come to hate us without the help of Chimpy McDeath, here are the reasons given by the author:

-The relative changes in the international stature of America and France. "No nation likes to see itself slipping on the scale of grandeur. It is human nature to resent those that replace it."

-Our opposition to the French at Suez, and the supplying of small arms to the Tunisians (i.e., interfering with their ill-gotten colonial booty).

-The lack of contacts by the French with everyday Americans, leaving them to garner their impressions of us from "films, books, soldiers, business men and tourists." One French journalist quoted in the article notes - with requisite disdain, naturellement - that the uncouth Yanks "drink Coca-cola among the most magnificent vineyards." Quel horreur!

-And, lastly, the deliberately distorted image of Americans painted by European intellectuals, charicaturizing us as a nation obsessed with, among other things, rock and roll, juke boxes and stock car races.

So there you have it. If only we didn't behave like Marlon Brando in The Wild One, everybody would love us. Now that we have that solved, I'll leave you with this:

There is no hate for the United States in France. France remains friendly to the United States. But the French people just don't like the American people.

That little tidbit was said by Charles de Gaulle. Leave it to either a Frenchman or John Kerry to come up with the nuanced position of "our country doesn't hate your country, our people just hate your people." Whatever.

Posted by Deus Ex Macrame at September 27, 2004 10:23 PM | TrackBack
Comments

The French managed to celebrate the liberation of Paris without mentioning Generals Eisenhower and Patton -- or, for that matter, Americans in general.

15,000 dead in Patton's army and two months to get to Paris from Normandy after D-Day, and no mention of the Americans.

Posted by: Fausta at September 28, 2004 11:56 AM

Holy cow -- I just read your link. On the one hand, I can't believe they're basically just "disappearing" the U.S. during their liberation celebrations like some sort of disfavored Soviet apparachik. On the other hand, I can believe it, because it's France 2. During the invasion of Iraq, I once witnessed the following exchange between (I think) a CNN anchor in the U.S. and a France 2 reporter in Baghdad (paraphrasing):


CNN Anchor: What about these reports from the Iraqi Information Minister about Americans intentionally bombing a hospital, killing a bunch of civilians.

France 2 reporter: Yes, yes, it's true.

CNN Anchor: You've been over there to see it?

France 2 reporter: Well, no, I haven't seen it myself, but obviously it is true...

Posted by: Deus ex Macrame at September 28, 2004 05:01 PM

For a brilliant analysis of French anti-Americanism see Jean-Francois Revel's "Anti-Americanism." He says the French always prefer envy to achievement, and likens the European anti-Americans to a cult, so obesessive are their feelings.

Posted by: carl ryan at September 28, 2004 09:23 PM


You know, in France, the people doesn't hate you ! No, the french people just think americans are too (like Bush) pretentious, hipocriticals (like Bush) and dominating (like Bush)…

Posted by: Maraut at November 2, 2004 10:31 AM

Excuse my French, but: Certainment il y en a qui haissent notre president, et nous, pourtant, l'ont choisi encore. Ca, par extension, suggeste fortement qu'il y a des francais qui haisse le peuple americain. Aussi certainment, il y en a d'autres (comme tu dis) qui nous dedaignent au lieu de nous haisser.

De toute facon, on s'en fait pas. L'amitie des Francais n'est pas notre plus grande concerne ces jours ci. En plus, la politique internationale francaise documente sur ce blog (e.g., joint naval maneuvers with China to threaten Taiwan, opposing U.N. sanctions against the Sudanese government to stop the genocidal janjaweed, accepting huge kickbacks from Saddam under the Oil For Food program...)a cause beaucoup d'americain de ne plus vouloire etre allie a la France.

For our English-speaking readers:

There are plenty of French people who hate president Bush, and since we've re-elected him they will no doubt hate us as well. There are also French people who simply disdain us rather than hating us.

Basically, we don't care. In fact, given France's foreign policy, particularly in recent years, many Americans no longer _want_ to be allied with France.

I love reading Rostand and Voltaire, but that's about the only thing I want to have to do with France these days.

Posted by: Andrew at November 4, 2004 06:12 PM

sizepro, sizepro, size pro, male enhancement, penis enlargement, penis pills, penis enlargement pills, penis pill, penis enlargement pill, best penis pills, best penis enlargement pills, best penis pill, best penis enlargement pill, male enhancement pills, male enhancement pill, penis pills, penis enlargement pills, penis pill, penis enlargement pill, best penis pills, best penis enlargement pills, best penis pill, best penis enlargement pill, penis enlargement pills review, penis pills review, average penis size, penis size, increase penis size, average male penis size, normal penis size, penis size chart, penis size picture, penis size survey, size matter, does size matter, penis enlargement exercises, penis enlargement exercise, penis enlargement techniques, penis enlargement technique, penis, penis exercises, penis exercise, jelq, jelq

Posted by: penis enlargement [TypeKey Profile Page] at June 8, 2005 12:16 AM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?